Student wine scores from “50 Shades of Rosé Wine” class

Left from photo above:
Château Gassier Le Pas du Moine Rosé 2025, $32, AOC Côtes de Provence Cru Sainte-Victoire, Provence, France, Vinious says 92 pts, FSW students say: A
Chehalem Rosé of Pinot Noir 2024, $20, Willamette Valley, Oregon, Wine Enthusiast says 90 pts, FSW students say: B
Alexander Valley Vineyards Rosé of Sangiovese 2024, $21, Sonoma County, California, James Suckling says 90 pts, FSW students say: B+
Marqués de Caćeres Rosado Rioja 2025, $10, DOC Rioja, Spain, James Suckling says 90 pts, FSW students say: B
Château de Ségriès Tavel Rosé 2025, $28, AOC Tavel, Southern Rhône, Wine Enthusiast says 92 pts, FSW students say: C+